CONSUMER LAW | The CJEU on unfair price adjustment clauses in energy supply contracts

On 24 September 2026, the EU Court of Justice (CJEU) issued its judgment in case C-900/24 (SVB – Neues Schweizer Viertel Betriebs + Service GmbH & Co. KG v Glarner Straße 5 GbR), concerning unfair price adjustment clauses in long-term energy supply contracts governed by German law. The judgment interprets Articles 6(1) and 7(1) of Council Directive (EEC) No. 93/13 of 5 April 1993 (on unfair terms in consumer contracts) (the Directive), which provide that unfair terms are not binding on consumers and require Member States to ensure adequate and effective means to prevent their continued use.

The case concerned a district heating supply contract containing a price adjustment clause declared void for lack of transparency. The customer sought reimbursement of the price increases paid under it. The referring court asked whether national rules could preserve those increases where the customer had not challenged them within three years (under the “three-year rule” developed by German case law) and allow the supplier to replace the invalid clause unilaterally.

The CJEU held that Articles 6(1) and 7(1) of the Directive preclude both practices. The three-year rule would preserve the effects of an unfair term to the consumer’s detriment and weaken the deterrent effect pursued by the Directive. Indeed, if national courts could fill the gap left by an unfair term by supplementing the contract, traders would remain tempted to use such terms, knowing that, even if declared void, the contract would in any event be adjusted by the court so as to safeguard their interests. The Court also rejected the possibility for energy suppliers to remedy the unfairness by unilaterally replacing the clause for the future. The ruling highlights the need for energy suppliers to ensure fair and transparent price adjustment clauses from the outset.

Newsletter n. 122 – October 2026